• News
  • Life
  • TV & Film
  • Beauty
  • Style
  • Home
  • News
    • Celebrity
    • Entertainment
    • Politics
    • Royal Family
  • Life
    • Animals
    • Food & Drink
    • Women's Health
    • Mental Health
    • Sex & Relationships
    • Travel
    • Real Life
  • TV & Film
    • True Crime
    • Documentaries
    • Netflix
    • BBC
    • ITV
    • Tyla Recommends
  • Beauty
    • Hair
    • Make-up
    • Skincare
  • Style
    • Home
    • Fashion
    • Shopping
  • Advertise
  • Terms
  • Privacy & Cookies
  • LADbible Group
  • LADbible
  • UNILAD
  • SPORTbible
  • GAMINGbible
  • UNILAD Tech
  • FOODbible
  • License Our Content
  • About Us & Contact
  • Jobs
  • Latest
  • Topics A-Z
  • Authors
Facebook
Instagram
X
Threads
TikTok
Submit Your Content
Horrifying true story behind new Netflix show people can only watch ‘during the day time’

Home> Entertainment> Netflix

Published 17:23 28 Oct 2025 GMT

Horrifying true story behind new Netflix show people can only watch ‘during the day time’

Tyla spoke with Chris DiCesare, the real-life man at the centre of Netflix's True Haunting about what really happened in Erie Hall

Madison Burgess

Madison Burgess

google discoverFollow us on Google Discover

Chris DiCesare, the man whose story Netflix's toe-curling True Haunting is based on, has revealed the horrifying truth behind the spooky show.

For those unfamiliar, the terrifying TV series landed with a bang on 7 October and has left even the most hardcore horror fans unable to sleep after watching, forcing them to stream it only in the daytime.

True Haunting is about real-life paranormal hauntings, as documented by the people who survived them.

As well as chilling first-hand interviews with people like Chris, it also includes dramatisations and scripted reenactments, which were put together and directed by horror filmmaker James Wan, best known for Saw, The Conjuring, and Insidious franchises.

Advert

It delves into two different stories across five episodes: The Ghost Boy of Erie Hall and This House Murdered Me.

Following the reaction to the blood-curdling show, Tyla spoke with Chris, who appeared in the programme for the former, to open up about the paranormal activity he experienced during his first year of college in the 1980s.

It all began in SUNY Geneseo's Erie Hall, in dorm room C2D1, to be specific, where Chris moved in with his roommate, Paul.

From then, he claims to have been plagued by full-bodied apparitions, voices, physical attacks and spine-chilling encounters.

Shortly after moving into Erie Hall, he began hearing disembodied voices and thought he was losing his mind - but that was only the beginning.

Things got so out of hand that Chris's roommate fled, and a priest was called in to perform an exorcism, and Lorraine Warren refused to shake his hand as she 'didn't want to know' his future.

Speaking to Tyla, Chris admitted: "The physical marks have disappeared, but I am not sure that the psychological damage ever will. Trauma changes the way that a person thinks, as well as how they view the world around them.

"I wonder to myself, each and every day, if today will be the day that ‘that thing’ comes back. It has been forty years since the events at Erie Hall took place, and logic suggests that it is now all over, but my mind cannot help but to go back to the thought that it happened once, so it can happen again."

Chris DiCesare spoke to Tyla about his real-life paranormal experience that was depicted in the Netflix show (Netflix)
Chris DiCesare spoke to Tyla about his real-life paranormal experience that was depicted in the Netflix show (Netflix)

Delving into the traumatic moment he was 'attacked' by a ghost in the shower, he recalled: "As I stood under the water, I saw a human-shaped shadow – with a tilted head like the ghost had – on the ceiling above me. I ran out into the middle of the bathroom, almost falling because of my wet feet, but no one was there but me.

"Then, I realised that there could be no human shadow on the ceiling, because that’s where the room’s sole light source was.

"My own shadow was on the floor, spreading off from my feet. I decided that I was going to call the priest back. But first, I walked back into the shower stall to turn off the water, to prevent the bathroom from possibly flooding.

"It was then that the attack occurred. It felt as though I had been stabbed in the back with a knife."

Chris continued: "I turned to defend myself and blindly punched into the area where I thought the assailant would be.

"I tore the shower curtain off of the rod, and saw that I was still alone in the room. That’s when I looked over at the mirrors above the sinks to see that my back had three long scratches on it. Terrifying."

Another instance saw him come face to face with an apparition - a moment he said will 'forever be etched in his mind'.

He recalled how he 'caught some slight movement in the corner of his right eye' and when he turned around, he 'saw a young man – head tilted to the side as though his neck was broken – wearing some style of clothing that I could not recognise, standing inside Paul’s stereo'.

Chris admitted he still sleeps with the light on, forty years after the horrifying ordeal (Netflix)
Chris admitted he still sleeps with the light on, forty years after the horrifying ordeal (Netflix)

He continued: "My first thought was that, at some point, I had fallen asleep and that this was simply a dream. But I looked around quickly and confirmed I was actually sitting at my desk chair, that my running magazine was still opened to the page that I had been reading, and that the box of candy that I had been eating from was still in my hand.

"The thing’s head moved slightly forward, and with that, I absolutely panicked."

Chris said it was only when Paul saw the same thing that he had with no prior knowledge, that he understood he was 'not going crazy, but rather some ‘dead thing’ was now in their room'.

A boy named Tommy, who allegedly hanged himself on the Geneseo campus, was rumoured to be the spirit that haunted Chris.

Chris and his roommate also theorised that the ghost could be that of Thomas Boyd, a Revolutionary War soldier, based on a connection they discovered between their own ancestor and the discovery of Boyd's body.

As seen in the documentary, he learned that it was one of his mother's ancestors who discovered the lieutenant's mutilated body.

Now, two decades after the months-long hauntings, Chris has admitted he still has to sleep with the light on.

I think after this, so will we...

Featured Image Credit: Netflix

Topics: Netflix, TV And Film, Halloween, True Life, Real Life, Tyla Exclusive, Documentaries

Madison Burgess
Madison Burgess

Madison is a Journalist at Tyla with a keen interest in lifestyle, entertainment and culture. She graduated from the University of Sheffield with a first-class degree in Journalism Studies, and has previously written for DMG Media as a Showbiz Reporter and Audience Writer.

Advert

Advert

Advert

Choose your content:

an hour ago
2 hours ago
3 hours ago
  • Eric McCandless via Getty Images
    an hour ago

    List of very strict rules Oscars seat fillers have to follow

    Among the celebrities at tonight's 98th Academy Awards are a number of seat fillers - but the role comes with a strict set of rules

    Entertainment
  • ABC
    2 hours ago

    Jimmy Kimmel makes brutal dig at Trump during Oscars speech

    Jimmy Kimmel just 'threw shade' at Donald Trump, Melania, and CBS, while presenting an award at the Oscars

    Entertainment
  • Emma McIntyre/Getty Images
    3 hours ago

    Why Sean Penn didn’t show up to Oscars after viewers left divided over his win

    Sean Penn just won the Oscar for Best Supporting Actor for One Battle After Another

    Entertainment
  • ABC
    3 hours ago

    Oscar winners break extremely rare record and viewers are left shocked

    Oscars viewers have been left shocked by the unexpected winners for Live Action Short Film

    Entertainment
  • ‘Uncomfortable truth’ about Punch the monkey’s heartbreaking story going viral
  • Surprising yearly 'tax' only women pay every year without even realising
  • Netflix fans urged to watch these shows after watching ‘thriller of the century’ with horrifying twist
  • Netflix documentary about family ‘stuck in time’ after cruise ship mystery leaves viewers heartbroken