Ben Williams
As questions continue to swirl over whether the US could ever return to military conscription, attention has shifted to a more specific issue: who would actually be ruled out if a draft were activated.
That is because being on the government’s radar is only one part of the process. Registration, eligibility, and induction are separate stages, and they do not automatically lead from one to the next.
Even in a national emergency, people called up in the US would still be assessed before being sent into service, with rules allowing certain exemptions, deferrals, and fitness-based exclusions.
This distinction matters now more than ever, after a proposed change to the Selective Service system put the subject back in the spotlight. The change itself does not create an active draft, but it has renewed scrutiny of what would happen if one were ever authorised.
Advert
That includes the categories of people who could avoid standard military service entirely or be treated differently under the law.
Under the proposal, eligible men aged 18 to 25 would be automatically registered in the Selective Service pool starting in December if it is approved. When the suggested change was announced, the Selective Service System’s new rule says: "This statutory change transfers responsibility for registration from individual men to SSS through integration with federal data sources." While this could initially be a cause for alarm to some, automatic registration would not itself amount to an active draft.
As noted by FOX 11 Los Angeles, the exemptions begin with several groups who are treated differently from the outset, including non-immigrant visa holders on valid student, visitor, tourist, or diplomatic visas, active-duty personnel, and service academy cadets. People who are incarcerated or institutionalised are also covered by separate rules, although they may still have to register within 30 days of release.
There are also categories of people who may still be required to register, but who could avoid standard military service if a draft were activated. For instance, ministers and divinity students can claim a ministerial deferment.
Those who are the sole support for dependants, such as children or elderly parents, can apply for a hardship deferment. Conscientious objectors may also be assigned to non-combatant service or civilian alternative service if they can prove that their opposition to war is based on moral, ethical, or religious beliefs.
Physical and mental fitness would also remain a major factor. As reported when Tyla covered how Barron Trump could avoid army conscription, men called up in a crisis would be examined for mental, physical, and moral fitness before being deferred or exempted from military service or inducted into the Armed Forces. That means medical or physical limitations could still affect whether a person is accepted, and in some cases, even height can become an issue. According to Veteran.com and the United States Army official site for recruiting, the height range for male recruits starts at 5"0 and ends at 6"8.
For now, however, the key point is that the US does not currently have an active draft, and it has not had one since 1973. Congress and the President would both need to authorise one, while recent coverage also states that women are not currently required to register under the existing system.