tyla homepage
tyla homepage
  • News
    • Politics
    • Entertainment
    • Celebrity
  • Entertainment
    • Celebrity
  • Life
    • Animals
    • Food & Drink
    • Women's Health
    • Mental Health
    • Sex & Relationships
    • Travel
    • Real Life
  • TV & Film
    • True Crime
    • Tyla Recommends
  • Astrology
  • Beauty
    • Hair
    • Make-up
    • Skincare
  • Style
    • Home
  • Advertise
  • Terms
  • Privacy & Cookies
  • LADbible Group
  • LADbible
  • UNILAD
  • SPORTbible
  • GAMINGbible
  • UNILAD Tech
  • FOODbible
  • License Our Content
  • About Us & Contact
  • Jobs
  • Latest
  • Archive
  • Topics A-Z
  • Authors
Facebook
Instagram
X
Threads
TikTok
Submit Your Content
Ex-Mormon reveals real reason they 'look the same' as scandalous season 2 of Mormon wives show leaves viewers in disbelief
Home>Entertainment>TV & Film
Updated 12:47 15 May 2025 GMT+1Published 12:48 15 May 2025 GMT+1

Ex-Mormon reveals real reason they 'look the same' as scandalous season 2 of Mormon wives show leaves viewers in disbelief

YouTube star Alyssa Grenfell spilt the tea on the physical resemblances between Mormon women

Rhianna Benson

Rhianna Benson

google discoverFollow us on Google Discover
Featured Image Credit: Disney/Hulu

Topics: The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives, Life, Real Life, True Life, TV And Film, Reality TV, US News

Rhianna Benson
Rhianna Benson

Rhianna is an Entertainment Journalist at LADbible Group, working across LADbible, UNILAD and Tyla. She has a Masters in News Journalism from the University of Salford and a Masters in Ancient History from the University of Edinburgh. She previously worked as a Celebrity Reporter for OK! and New Magazines, and as a TV Writer for Reach PLC.

X

@rhiannaBjourno

Advert

Advert

Advert

Whilst the 'all Mormon women look the same' claim might be considered rather controversial, a former member of the niche community has voiced her agreement, believing there to be a valid reason for this observation.

The revelation came to light last year amid the success of a brand new reality TV series, The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives.

The Hulu docu-series - which centred on a group of Mormon influencers following a 'swinging scandal' that happened some years earlier - became an instant hit, and was praised for giving a raw insight into the realities of the religion.

Little side-note to fans of the show: the second series lands on Disney+ and Hulu today (15 May) - eek! - and by the sounds of things, it's already set tongues wagging.

Advert

"God the secret lives of mormon wives are like the best thing to happen to reality tv since jersey shore. it feeds all of my reality tv needs i swearrrrrr," one new viewer gushed online.

Another added: "At this point i’m not sleeping im too into secret lives of mormon wives. F**k it."

The first instalment of the show focussed primarily on Utah-based mum Taylor Frankie Paul, who divorced her husband Tate after discovering he and several other Salt Lake City parents had allegedly been engaging in intimate affairs with one another.

The scandal went viral at the time, with spectators seemingly blindsided that such saucy soirees would even be considered tempting in such a die-hard Christian community.

Amidst the praise, however, last year's did viewers raised their queries regarding one aspect of the show, claiming they couldn't tell a number of the show's female stars apart.

"I need the cast of The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives to wear name tags please, these women all look the same," one wrote on social media, as another hit out online: "People saying all Utah women look the same & i genuinely didn’t understand until i started watching the secret lives of mormon wives. I genuinely cannot tell the difference between a majority of these women."

Taylor and Tate Paul were the lead stars of the first series (Hulu)
Taylor and Tate Paul were the lead stars of the first series (Hulu)

"I’m watching secret lives of Mormon wives and I can’t tell these woman apart they all look the same but I’m enjoying," a third continued.

Apparently, however, there's actually very good reason for such confusion, with another former Mormon spilling the tea on the alleged similarities.

Speaking on YouTube, Alyssa Grenfell - who departed from the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints in Utah back in 2017 - claimed the resemblances amongst women could be pinned on the small gene pool, with Mormons preferring to stick together.

"Have you ever wondered why some people 'look Mormon'?" she previously asked. "Mormons really only marry other Mormons.

"You can’t marry in a Mormon temple unless it’s two Mormons getting married, this in large part has made it so that the gene pool is actually very small — especially in a place like Utah, where Mormons fled and went to Utah to be able to practice polygamy in peace."

A former Mormon confirmed there's a reason for any resemblance (YouTube)
A former Mormon confirmed there's a reason for any resemblance (YouTube)

Grenfell continued: "Those Mormons were only making babies with other Mormons for a very long time, and the only opportunity to make the gene pool a little larger is to convert people."

She also touched on the overly-friendliness of many within the Mormon community, possibly alluding to the frequency of sex scandals.

"I think another reason for this is the Mormon vibe which is often super, hyper friendly, almost too friendly," Grenfell explained.

"Mormons are taught to proselytize and share their religion... I think that Mormon culture is very copycat.”

You can watch the second series of The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives on Hulu and Disney+ now.

Choose your content:

10 hours ago
11 hours ago
12 hours ago
  • Dominik Bindl/Getty Images
    10 hours ago

    Millie Bobby Brown ‘hopeful’ to carry child following adoption of baby girl

    The Stranger Things star has revealed her dream to welcome another child

    Entertainment
  • Kym Illman/Getty Images
    11 hours ago

    Kim Kardashian’s controversial F1 appearance brutally trolled by Grand Prix winner who beat Lewis Hamilton

    Kim Kardashian ruffled many feathers at the Monaco Grand Prix

    Entertainment
  • Peacock
    12 hours ago

    Love Island USA star Melanie defended over her appearance change after cruel trolls resurface old photos

    Going on Love Island is not for the weak, after trolls have been targeting Melanie

    Entertainment
  • A Mug of Life/YouTube
    12 hours ago

    Niall Horan shares the 'weirdest' part of Liam Payne’s death

    Liam Payne died in 2024 after falling from the third-floor balcony of his Buenos Aires hotel, having been visiting Niall Horan in Argentina

    Entertainment
  • Mormon Wives star Jessi Draper shares cryptic messages following Jordan Ngatikaura divorce
  • Taylor Frankie Paul addresses domestic violence reports in first televised interview
  • Taylor Frankie Paul speaks out on how her daughter has been affected by 2023 video leak
  • Taylor Frankie Paul breaks silence on alleged domestic incident after police issue statement